I've been working up a business idea with a couple of people
here in the city.
Since it uses relatively off the shelf parts I was hoping that it would be straightforward to put together a prototype and pitch it around.
The sad reality is that even a cursory search through the tarpit that is the
USPTO patent database came up with multiple conflicting patents which
may cover what we're trying to do, or not.
Over 16,000 patents were granted in December 2002.
Over 184,000 for the year (according to the site).
There are over 2M active patents (assuming an even expiration period of 17 years), with almost half granted in the past five years.
What's my point?
As a small-time techie trying to make a buck, I have two options -- mine the patent database for ideas (and license appropriately) or ignore it entirely.
I'm far better off blindly ignoring what's been done and trudging onward, ignoring the patents that exist, instead of using the system the way I thought it was intended: allow inventors to share their inventions and in return get a monopoly on the value of that invention for a period of time.
There are so many trashy patents being filed (and granted) that the whole system has been corrupted.
The very people who claim to be out to protect the value of intellectual property are destroying it.
The system all but encourages you to ignore others' intellectual property (in the patent form) rather than make use of it.
I'm sure there's many valid, fine patents in the mess, but they're useless to anyone without a high powered and well funded legal research staff.
And just to discourage me further, I came across several IBM patents which were filed in 1997-1998 having to do with web technologies.
I now know why I got hosed so badly by IBM...I thought I was supposed to help other employees by answering questions.
Instead I should have replied Interesting problem, tough noogies, hung up, and then written up the solution as a patent disclosure.
e.p.c. posted this at 22:12 GMT on 6-Jan-2003 .
Archive Link
I did drive up to Boston on Saturday for Alister's bachelor bash.
It was small, relatively uneventful, and fun.
After spending Sunday afternoon recuperating, I drove back to Brooklyn (said drive seemed to take forever due to the weather and the throbbing in my not-quite-broken again left foot).
e.p.c. posted this at 22:31 GMT on 6-Jan-2003 .
Archive Link